Publications

2017
Julia M Shifman and Papo, Niv . 2017. Editorial Overview: Engineering And Design: New Trends In Designer Proteins. Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol., 45, Pp. iv–vi.
Eitan Rabinovich, Heyne, Michael , Bakhman, Anna , Kosloff, Mickey , Shifman, Julia M, and Papo, Niv . 2017. Identifying Residues That Determine Scf Molecular-Level Interactions Through A Combination Of Experimental And In Silico Analyses. J. Mol. Biol., 429, Pp. 97–114. Abstract
The stem cell factor (SCF)/c-Kit receptor tyrosine kinase complex-with its significant roles in hematopoiesis and angiogenesis-is an attractive target for rational drug design. There is thus a need to map, in detail, the SCF/c-Kit interaction sites and the mechanisms that modulate this interaction. While most residues in the direct SCF/c-Kit binding interface can be identified from the existing crystal structure of the complex, other residues that affect binding through protein unfolding, intermolecular interactions, allosteric or long-distance electrostatic effects cannot be directly inferred. Here, we describe an efficient method for protein-wide epitope mapping using yeast surface display. A library of single SCF mutants that span the SCF sequence was screened for decreased affinity to soluble c-Kit. Sequencing of selected clones allowed the identification of mutations that reduce SCF binding affinity to c-Kit. Moreover, the screening of these SCF clones for binding to a structural antibody helped identify mutations that result in small or large conformational changes in SCF. Computational modeling of the experimentally identified mutations showed that these mutations reduced the binding affinity through one of the three scenarios: through SCF destabilization, through elimination of favorable SCF/c-Kit intermolecular interactions, or through allosteric changes. Eight SCF variants were expressed and purified. Experimentally measured in vitro binding affinities of these mutants to c-Kit confirmed both the yeast surface display selection results and the computational predictions. This study has thus identified the residues crucial for c-Kit/SCF binding and has demonstrated the advantages of using a combination of computational and combinatorial methods for epitope mapping.
2016
Jason Shirian, Sharabi, Oz , and Shifman, Julia M. 2016. Cold Spots In Protein Binding. Trends Biochem. Sci., 41, Pp. 739–745. Abstract
Understanding the energetics and architecture of protein-binding interfaces is important for basic research and could potentially facilitate the design of novel binding domains for biotechnological applications. It is well accepted that a few key residues at binding interfaces (binding hot spots) are responsible for contributing most to the free energy of binding. In this opinion article, we introduce a new concept of 'binding cold spots', or interface positions occupied by suboptimal amino acids. Such positions exhibit a potential for affinity enhancement through various mutations. We give several examples of cold spots from different protein-engineering studies and argue that identification of such positions is crucial for studies of protein evolution and protein design.
Lior Rosenfeld, Heyne, Michael , Shifman, Julia M, and Papo, Niv . 2016. Protein Engineering By Combined Computational And In Vitro Evolution Approaches. Trends Biochem. Sci., 41, Pp. 421–433. Abstract
Two alternative strategies are commonly used to study protein-protein interactions (PPIs) and to engineer protein-based inhibitors. In one approach, binders are selected experimentally from combinatorial libraries of protein mutants that are displayed on a cell surface. In the other approach, computational modeling is used to explore an astronomically large number of protein sequences to select a small number of sequences for experimental testing. While both approaches have some limitations, their combination produces superior results in various protein engineering applications. Such applications include the design of novel binders and inhibitors, the enhancement of affinity and specificity, and the mapping of binding epitopes. The combination of these approaches also aids in the understanding of the specificity profiles of various PPIs.
Ariel Erijman and Shifman, Julia M. 2016. Ras/Effector Interactions From Structural And Biophysical Perspective. Mini Rev. Med. Chem., 16, Pp. 370–375. Abstract
RAS is a molecular switch that regulates a large number of pathways through interactions with many effector proteins. Most RAS/effector complexes are short-lived, demonstrating fast association and fast dissociation rate and Kds ranging from 10(-8)-10(-5) M, compatible with the signaling function of these interactions in the cell. RAS effectors share little sequence homology but all contain an RAS binding domain that exhibits ubiquitin fold. All effectors bind to the same epitope on RAS by forming an intermolecular beta sheet and creating a number of favorable hydrogen bonds and salt bridges across the binding interface. Several hot-spots on both RAS and effector molecules constitute a general recognition mode. RAS/effector interactions occur only when RAS is found in the active, GTP-bound state, and are disrupted upon GTP hydrolysis, most probably due to increased flexibility of the RAS molecule. Recent NMR studies demonstrate how in the presence of multiple binding partners, RAS prefers certain effectors to others. The hierarchy of these interactions could be altered for RAS oncogenic mutants, thus perturbing the network of the downstream signaling. Insights obtained through biophysical and structural studies of effectors interacting with RAS and its mutants establish the basic principles that could be used for designing drugs in RAS-associated diseases.
Isabel Leung, Dekel, Ayelet , Shifman, Julia M, and Sidhu, Sachdev S. 2016. Saturation Scanning Of Ubiquitin Variants Reveals A Common Hot Spot For Binding To Usp2 And Usp21. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A., 113, Pp. 8705–8710. Abstract
A detailed understanding of the molecular mechanisms whereby ubiquitin (Ub) recognizes enzymes in the Ub proteasome system is crucial for understanding the biological function of Ub. Many structures of Ub complexes have been solved and, in most cases, reveal a large structural epitope on a common face of the Ub molecule. However, owing to the generally weak nature of these interactions, it has been difficult to map in detail the functional contributions of individual Ub side chains to affinity and specificity. Here we took advantage of Ub variants (Ubvs) that bind tightly to particular Ub-specific proteases (USPs) and used phage display and saturation scanning mutagenesis to comprehensively map functional epitopes within the structural epitopes. We found that Ubvs that bind to USP2 or USP21 contain a remarkably similar core functional epitope, or ``hot spot,'' consisting mainly of positions that are conserved as the wild type sequence, but also some positions that prefer mutant sequences. The Ubv core functional epitope contacts residues that are conserved in the human USP family, and thus it is likely important for the interactions of Ub across many family members.
2015
Lior Rosenfeld, Shirian, Jason , Zur, Yuval , Levaot, Noam , Shifman, Julia M, and Papo, Niv . 2015. Combinatorial And Computational Approaches To Identify Interactions Of Macrophage Colony-Stimulating Factor (M-Csf) And Its Receptor C-Fms. J. Biol. Chem., 290, Pp. 26180–26193. Abstract
The molecular interactions between macrophage colony-stimulating factor (M-CSF) and the tyrosine kinase receptor c-FMS play a key role in the immune response, bone metabolism, and the development of some cancers. Because no x-ray structure is available for the human M-CSF · c-FMS complex, the binding epitope for this complex is largely unknown. Our goal was to identify the residues that are essential for binding of the human M-CSF to c-FMS. For this purpose, we used a yeast surface display (YSD) approach. We expressed a combinatorial library of monomeric M-CSF (M-CSFM) single mutants and screened this library to isolate variants with reduced affinity for c-FMS using FACS. Sequencing yielded a number of single M-CSFM variants with mutations both in the direct binding interface and distant from the binding site. In addition, we used computational modeling to map the identified mutations onto the M-CSFM structure and to classify the mutations into three groups as follows: those that significantly decrease protein stability; those that destroy favorable intermolecular interactions; and those that decrease affinity through allosteric effects. To validate the YSD and computational data, M-CSFM and three variants were produced as soluble proteins; their affinity and structure were analyzed; and very good correlations with both YSD data and computational predictions were obtained. By identifying the M-CSFM residues critical for M-CSF · c-FMS interactions, we have laid down the basis for a deeper understanding of the M-CSF · c-FMS signaling mechanism and for the development of target-specific therapeutic agents with the ability to sterically occlude the M-CSF·c-FMS binding interface.
Uwe Kafurke, Erijman, Ariel , Aizner, Yonatan , Shifman, Julia M, and Eichler, Jutta . 2015. Synthetic Peptides Mimicking The Binding Site Of Human Acetylcholinesterase For Its Inhibitor Fasciculin 2. J. Pept. Sci., 21, Pp. 723–730. Abstract
Molecules capable of mimicking protein binding and/or functional sites present useful tools for a range of biomedical applications, including the inhibition of protein-ligand interactions. Such mimics of protein binding sites can currently be generated through structure-based design and chemical synthesis. Computational protein design could be further used to optimize protein binding site mimetics through rationally designed mutations that improve intermolecular interactions or peptide stability. Here, as a model for the study, we chose an interaction between human acetylcholinesterase (hAChE) and its inhibitor fasciculin-2 (Fas) because the structure and function of this complex is well understood. Structure-based design of mimics of the hAChE binding site for Fas yielded a peptide that binds to Fas at micromolar concentrations. Replacement of hAChE residues known to be essential for its interaction with Fas with alanine, in this peptide, resulted in almost complete loss of binding to Fas. Computational optimization of the hAChE mimetic peptide yielded a variant with slightly improved affinity to Fas, indicating that more rounds of computational optimization will be required to obtain peptide variants with greatly improved affinity for Fas. CD spectra in the absence and presence of Fas point to conformational changes in the peptide upon binding to Fas. Furthermore, binding of the optimized hAChE mimetic peptide to Fas could be inhibited by hAChE, providing evidence for a hAChE-specific peptide-Fas interaction.
2014
Oz Sharabi, Shirian, Jason , Grossman, Moran , Lebendiker, Mario , Sagi, Irit , and Shifman, Julia . 2014. Affinity- And Specificity-Enhancing Mutations Are Frequent In Multispecific Interactions Between Timp2 And Mmps. Plos One, 9, Pp. e93712. Abstract
Multispecific proteins play a major role in controlling various functions such as signaling, regulation of transcription/translation, and immune response. Hence, a thorough understanding of the atomic-level principles governing multispecific interactions is important not only for the advancement of basic science but also for applied research such as drug design. Here, we study evolution of an exemplary multispecific protein, a Tissue Inhibitor of Matrix Metalloproteinases 2 (TIMP2) that binds with comparable affinities to more than twenty-six members of the Matrix Metalloproteinase (MMP) and the related ADAMs families. We postulate that due to its multispecific nature, TIMP2 is not optimized to bind to any individual MMP type, but rather embodies a compromise required for interactions with all MMPs. To explore this hypothesis, we perform computational saturation mutagenesis of the TIMP2 binding interface and predict changes in free energy of binding to eight MMP targets. Computational results reveal the non-optimality of the TIMP2 binding interface for all studied proteins, identifying many affinity-enhancing mutations at multiple positions. Several TIMP2 point mutants predicted to enhance binding affinity and/or binding specificity towards MMP14 were selected for experimental verification. Experimental results show high abundance of affinity-enhancing mutations in TIMP2, with some point mutations producing more than ten-fold improvement in affinity to MMP14. Our computational and experimental results collaboratively demonstrate that the TIMP2 sequence lies far from the fitness maximum when interacting with its target enzymes. This non-optimality of the binding interface and high potential for improvement might characterize all proteins evolved for binding to multiple targets.
Javier Murciano-Calles, McLaughlin, Megan E, Erijman, Ariel , Hooda, Yogesh , Chakravorty, Nishant , Martinez, Jose C, Shifman, Julia M, and Sidhu, Sachdev S. 2014. Alteration Of The C-Terminal Ligand Specificity Of The Erbin Pdz Domain By Allosteric Mutational Effects. J. Mol. Biol., 426, Pp. 3500–3508. Abstract
Modulation of protein binding specificity is important for basic biology and for applied science. Here we explore how binding specificity is conveyed in PDZ (postsynaptic density protein-95/discs large/zonula occludens-1) domains, small interaction modules that recognize various proteins by binding to an extended C terminus. Our goal was to engineer variants of the Erbin PDZ domain with altered specificity for the most C-terminal position (position 0) where a Val is strongly preferred by the wild-type domain. We constructed a library of PDZ domains by randomizing residues in direct contact with position 0 and in a loop that is close to but does not contact position 0. We used phage display to select for PDZ variants that bind to 19 peptide ligands differing only at position 0. To verify that each obtained PDZ domain exhibited the correct binding specificity, we selected peptide ligands for each domain. Despite intensive efforts, we were only able to evolve Erbin PDZ domain variants with selectivity for the aliphatic C-terminal side chains Val, Ile and Leu. Interestingly, many PDZ domains with these three distinct specificities contained identical amino acids at positions that directly contact position 0 but differed in the loop that does not contact position 0. Computational modeling of the selected PDZ domains shows how slight conformational changes in the loop region propagate to the binding site and result in different binding specificities. Our results demonstrate that second-sphere residues could be crucial in determining protein binding specificity.
Ariel Erijman, Rosenthal, Eran , and Shifman, Julia M. 2014. How Structure Defines Affinity In Protein-Protein Interactions. Plos One, 9, Pp. e110085. Abstract
Protein-protein interactions (PPI) in nature are conveyed by a multitude of binding modes involving various surfaces, secondary structure elements and intermolecular interactions. This diversity results in PPI binding affinities that span more than nine orders of magnitude. Several early studies attempted to correlate PPI binding affinities to various structure-derived features with limited success. The growing number of high-resolution structures, the appearance of more precise methods for measuring binding affinities and the development of new computational algorithms enable more thorough investigations in this direction. Here, we use a large dataset of PPI structures with the documented binding affinities to calculate a number of structure-based features that could potentially define binding energetics. We explore how well each calculated biophysical feature alone correlates with binding affinity and determine the features that could be used to distinguish between high-, medium- and low- affinity PPIs. Furthermore, we test how various combinations of features could be applied to predict binding affinity and observe a slow improvement in correlation as more features are incorporated into the equation. In addition, we observe a considerable improvement in predictions if we exclude from our analysis low-resolution and NMR structures, revealing the importance of capturing exact intermolecular interactions in our calculations. Our analysis should facilitate prediction of new interactions on the genome scale, better characterization of signaling networks and design of novel binding partners for various target proteins.
Yonatan Aizner, Sharabi, Oz , Shirian, Jason , Dakwar, George R, Risman, Marina , Avraham, Orly , and Shifman, Julia . 2014. Mapping Of The Binding Landscape For A Picomolar Protein-Protein Complex Through Computation And Experiment. Structure, 22, Pp. 636–645. Abstract
Our understanding of protein evolution would greatly benefit from mapping of binding landscapes, i.e., changes in protein-protein binding affinity due to all single mutations. However, experimental generation of such landscapes is a tedious task due to a large number of possible mutations. Here, we use a simple computational protocol to map the binding landscape for two homologous high-affinity complexes, involving a snake toxin fasciculin and acetylcholinesterase from two different species. To verify our computational predictions, we experimentally measure binding between 25 Fas mutants and the 2 enzymes. Both computational and experimental results demonstrate that the Fas sequence is close to the optimum when interacting with its targets, yet a few mutations could further improve Kd, kon, and koff. Our computational predictions agree well with experimental results and generate distributions similar to those observed in other high-affinity PPIs, demonstrating the potential of simple computational protocols in capturing realistic binding landscapes.
Ariel Erijman, Shifman, Julia M, and Peleg, Yoav . 2014. A Single-Tube Assembly Of Dna Using The Transfer-Pcr (Tpcr) Platform. Methods Mol. Biol., 1116, Pp. 89–101. Abstract
DNA cloning is a basic methodology employed for multiple applications in all life-science disciplines. In order to facilitate DNA cloning we developed Transfer-PCR (TPCR), a novel approach that integrates in a single tube, PCR amplification of the target DNA from an origin vector and its subsequent integration into the destination vector. TPCR can be applied for incorporation of DNA fragments into any desired position within a circular plasmid without the need for purification of the intermediate PCR product and without the use of any commercial kit. TPCR reaction is most efficient within a narrow range of primer concentrations. Adaptation of the TPCR should facilitate, simplify, and significantly reduce time and costs for DNA assembly, as well as protein engineering studies. In the current publication we describe a detailed protocol for implementation of the TPCR method for DNA assembly.
2013
Oz Sharabi, Erijman, Ariel , and Shifman, Julia M. 2013. Computational Methods For Controlling Binding Specificity. Methods Enzymol., 523, Pp. 41–59. Abstract
Learning to control, protein-binding specificity is useful for both fundamental and applied biology. In fundamental research, better understanding of complicated signaling networks could be achieved through engineering of regulator proteins to bind to only a subset of their effector proteins. In applied research such as drug design, nonspecific binding remains a major reason for failure of many drug candidates. However, developing antibodies that simultaneously inhibit several disease-associated pathways are a rising trend in pharmaceutical industry. Binding specificity could be manipulated experimentally through various display technologies that allow us to select desired binders from a large pool of candidate protein sequences. We developed an alternative approach for controlling binding specificity based on computational protein design. We can enhance binding specificity of a protein by computationally optimizing its sequence for better interactions with one target and worse interaction with alternative target(s). Moreover, we can design multispecific proteins that simultaneously interact with a predefined set of proteins. Unlike combinatorial techniques, our computational methods for manipulating binding specificity are fast, low cost and in principle are able to consider an unlimited number of desired and undesired binding partners.
Oz Sharabi, Shirian, Jason , and Shifman, Julia M. 2013. Predicting Affinity- And Specificity-Enhancing Mutations At Protein-Protein Interfaces. Biochem. Soc. Trans., 41, Pp. 1166–1169. Abstract
Manipulations of PPIs (protein-protein interactions) are important for many biological applications such as synthetic biology and drug design. Combinatorial methods have been traditionally used for such manipulations, failing, however, to explain the effects achieved. We developed a computational method for prediction of changes in free energy of binding due to mutation that bring about deeper understanding of the molecular forces underlying binding interactions. Our method could be used for computational scanning of binding interfaces and subsequent analysis of the interfacial sequence optimality. The computational method was validated in two biological systems. Computational saturated mutagenesis of a high-affinity complex between an enzyme AChE (acetylcholinesterase) and a snake toxin Fas (fasciculin) revealed the optimal nature of this interface with only a few predicted affinity-enhancing mutations. Binding measurements confirmed high optimality of this interface and identified a few mutations that could further improve interaction fitness. Computational interface scanning of a medium-affinity complex between TIMP-2 (tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases-2) and MMP (matrix metalloproteinase) 14 revealed a non-optimal nature of the binding interface with multiple mutations predicted to stabilize the complex. Experimental results corroborated our computational predictions, identifying a large number of mutations that improve the binding affinity for this interaction and some mutations that enhance binding specificity. Overall, our computational protocol greatly facilitates the discovery of affinity- and specificity-enhancing mutations and thus could be applied for design of potent and highly specific inhibitors of any PPI.
2011
Ariel Erijman, Aizner, Yonatan , and Shifman, Julia M. 2011. Multispecific Recognition: Mechanism, Evolution, And Design. Biochemistry, 50, Pp. 602–611. Abstract
Accumulating evidence shows that many particular proteins have evolved to bind multiple targets, including other proteins, peptides, DNA, and small molecule substrates. Multispecific recognition might be not only common but also necessary for the robustness of signaling and metabolic networks in the cell. It is also important for the immune response and for regulation of transcription and translation. Multispecificity presents an apparent paradox: How can a protein encoded by a single sequence accommodate numerous targets? Analysis of sequences and structures of multispecific proteins revealed a number of mechanisms that achieve multispecificity. Interestingly, similar mechanisms appear in antibody-antigen, T-cell receptor-peptide, protein-DNA, enzyme-substrate, and protein-protein complexes. Directed evolution and protein design experiments with multispecific proteins offer some interesting insights into the evolution of such proteins and help in the dissection of molecular interactions that mediate multispecificity. Understanding the basic principles governing multispecificity could greatly assist in the unraveling of various complex processes in the cell. In addition, through manipulation of functional multispecificity, novel proteins could be created for use in various biotechnological and biomedical applications.
Oz Sharabi, Yanover, Chen , Dekel, Ayelet , and Shifman, Julia M. 2011. Optimizing Energy Functions For Protein-Protein Interface Design. J. Comput. Chem., 32, Pp. 23–32. Abstract
Protein design methods have been originally developed for the design of monomeric proteins. When applied to the more challenging task of protein–protein complex design, these methods yield suboptimal results. In particular, they often fail to recapitulate favorable hydrogen bonds and electrostatic interactions across the interface. In this work, we aim to improve the energy function of the protein design program ORBIT to better account for binding interactions between proteins. By using the advanced machine learning framework of conditional random fields, we optimize the relative importance of all the terms in the energy function, attempting to reproduce the native side-chain conformations in protein–protein interfaces. We evaluate the performance of several optimized energy functions, each describes the van der Waals interactions using a different potential. In comparison with the original energy function, our best energy function (a) incorporates a much ``softer'' repulsive van der Waals potential, suitable for the discrete rotameric representation of amino acid side chains; (b) does not penalize burial of polar atoms, reflecting the frequent occurrence of polar buried residues in protein–protein interfaces; and (c) significantly up-weights the electrostatic term, attesting to the high importance of these interactions for protein–protein complex formation. Using this energy function considerably improves side chain placement accuracy for interface residues in a large test set of protein–protein complexes. Moreover, the optimized energy function recovers the native sequences of protein–protein interface at a higher rate than the default function and performs substantially better in predicting changes in free energy of binding due to mutations.
Ariel Erijman, Dantes, Ada , Bernheim, Reut , Shifman, Julia M, and Peleg, Yoav . 2011. Transfer-Pcr (Tpcr): A Highway For Dna Cloning And Protein Engineering. J. Struct. Biol., 175, Pp. 171–177. Abstract
DNA cloning and protein engineering are basic methodologies employed for various applications in all life-science disciplines. Manipulations of DNA however, could be a lengthy process that slows down subsequent experiments. To facilitate both DNA cloning and protein engineering, we present Transfer-PCR (TPCR), a novel approach that integrates in a single tube, PCR amplification of the target DNA from an origin vector and its subsequent integration into the destination vector. TPCR can be applied for incorporation of DNA fragments into any desired position within a circular plasmid without the need for purification of the intermediate PCR product and without the use of any commercial kit. Using several examples, we demonstrate the applicability of the TPCR platform for both DNA cloning and for multiple-site targeted mutagenesis. In both cases, we show that the TPCR reaction is most efficient within a narrow range of primer concentrations. In mutagenesis, TPCR is primarily advantageous for generation of combinatorial libraries of targeted mutants but could be also applied to generation of variants with specific multiple mutations throughout the target gene. Adaptation of the TPCR platform should facilitate, simplify and significantly reduce time and costs for diverse protein structure and functional studies.
Oz Sharabi, Dekel, Ayelet , and Shifman, Julia M. 2011. Triathlon For Energy Functions: Who Is The Winner For Design Of Protein-Protein Interactions?. Proteins, 79, Pp. 1487–1498. Abstract
Computational prediction of stabilizing mutations into monomeric proteins has become an almost ordinary task. Yet, computational stabilization of protein–protein complexes remains a challenge. Design of protein–protein interactions (PPIs) is impeded by the absence of an energy function that could reliably reproduce all favorable interactions between the binding partners. In this work, we present three energy functions: one function that was trained on monomeric proteins, while the other two were optimized by different techniques to predict side-chain conformations in a dataset of PPIs. The performances of these energy functions are evaluated in three different tasks related to design of PPIs: predicting side-chain conformations in PPIs, recovering native binding-interface sequences, and predicting changes in free energy of binding due to mutations. Our findings show that both functions optimized on side-chain repacking in PPIs are more suitable for PPI design compared to the function trained on monomeric proteins. Yet, no function performs best at all three tasks. Comparison of the three energy functions and their performances revealed that (1) burial of polar atoms should not be penalized significantly in PPI design as in single-protein design and (2) contribution of electrostatic interactions should be increased several-fold when switching from single-protein to PPI design. In addition, the use of a softer van der Waals potential is beneficial in cases when backbone flexibility is important. All things considered, we define an energy function that captures most of the nuances of the binding energetics and hence, should be used in future for design of PPIs.
2010
Daniel Filchtinski, Sharabi, Oz , Rüppel, Alma , Vetter, Ingrid R, Herrmann, Christian , and Shifman, Julia M. 2010. What Makes Ras An Efficient Molecular Switch: A Computational, Biophysical, And Structural Study Of Ras-Gdp Interactions With Mutants Of Raf. J. Mol. Biol., 399, Pp. 422–435. Abstract
Ras is a small GTP-binding protein that is an essential molecular switch for a wide variety of signaling pathways including the control of cell proliferation, cell cycle progression and apoptosis. In the GTP-bound state, Ras can interact with its effectors, triggering various signaling cascades in the cell. In the GDP-bound state, Ras looses its ability to bind to known effectors. The interaction of the GTP-bound Ras (Ras(GTP)) with its effectors has been studied intensively. However, very little is known about the much weaker interaction between the GDP-bound Ras (Ras(GDP)) and Ras effectors. We investigated the factors underlying the nucleotide-dependent differences in Ras interactions with one of its effectors, Raf kinase. Using computational protein design, we generated mutants of the Ras-binding domain of Raf kinase (Raf) that stabilize the complex with Ras(GDP). Most of our designed mutations narrow the gap between the affinity of Raf for Ras(GTP) and Ras(GDP), producing the desired shift in binding specificity towards Ras(GDP). A combination of our best designed mutation, N71R, with another mutation, A85K, yielded a Raf mutant with a 100-fold improvement in affinity towards Ras(GDP). The Raf A85K and Raf N71R/A85K mutants were used to obtain the first high-resolution structures of Ras(GDP) bound to its effector. Surprisingly, these structures reveal that the loop on Ras previously termed the switch I region in the Ras(GDP).Raf mutant complex is found in a conformation similar to that of Ras(GTP) and not Ras(GDP). Moreover, the structures indicate an increased mobility of the switch I region. This greater flexibility compared to the same loop in Ras(GTP) is likely to explain the natural low affinity of Raf and other Ras effectors to Ras(GDP). Our findings demonstrate that an accurate balance between a rigid, high-affinity conformation and conformational flexibility is required to create an efficient and stringent molecular switch.